Bagel love and a trip back to the 70s

Not many people remember their first encounter with a bagel, but I do.  Having grown up in the small town of Penn Yan in upstate New York, I missed out on cultural diversity.  Either I was completely self-absorbed or differences simply weren’t talked about. When I walked into Grant Hall as a freshman at Oneonta State College in 1979 all that changed.

grant hallI nearly fell over myself when I learned that some of the girls I’d be living with were Jewish. Outside of a global studies unit on the Holocaust, I had no frame of reference as to what it meant to practice Judaism and no concept whatsoever of traditional foods linked to their history. 

book of jewish foodThe word bagel, in German, means bracelet.  According to the Book of Jewish Food, the shape of the bagel – with no beginning and no end – symbolized the eternal cycle of life. Frequently sold by street vendors in baskets or on long sticks, it was the standard bread of Jews in Eastern Europe in the 17th century. 

Eventually when people immigrated to the United States, they brought the bagel with them and some made a living selling them from pushcarts in the Lower East Side of Manhattan.

Recognizing there was a big gap in my understanding of the world around me, I was naturally curious. Unfortunately, I lacked (as I sometimes still do) appropriate social protocols.  My roommate, Debbie, remembers me asking, “So, do you speak Jewish?”  Clearly I had a lot to learn. Maybe it was her patience, and that recognition of how much there was to learn, that eventually led me to a year of studying world religions at an interfaith seminary.

Thankfully, Debbie was willing to share not just her faith but a whole world that I had never experienced!

Debbie around 1979.  You can see the college bus in the background!

Debbie around 1979. You can see the college bus in the background!

When she brought me home to meet her family, she introduced me to Long Island flea markets, New York City, and bagels with lox.  I still love flea markets and New York City, but I’ve never been able to wrap myself around the lox.  Pass the cream cheese please.

During my 4 years in Oneonta, one of my pleasures was the bagel shop downtown where I tasted my first bagel. It was worth the bus ride or the long walk down the hill to get there and frequently ended up a stop on our late nights back to campus. Though a novelty at first, it became a part of my blood.  Of course bagel shops are all over the place today but you know what they say about your first love, right?

Bagels are not hard to make.  After months of hearing me list ingredients, contemplate whether or not you really need the barley malt and why bagels have to be boiled before baking, my daughter (a die-hard bagel lover!) finally tired of waiting, pulled out the bread bowl and made the bagels herself!

IMG_2589Since then we’ve made bagels plenty of times.  I haven’t experimented with the barley malt that many cookbooks say make them taste and look like a bagel-store-bagel.  I’ll get to it.  Since I try to keep things as simple as possible, I question whether I really need it.  We have, however, experimented with things already in our cupboard like dried blueberries or cinnamon and raisins. 

I’m still working on making mine a classic bagel with just the perfect crust and rise, you’ll likely have to play with a few batches, too.  For me, the process is as important as the results. Even if they’re not perfect, they’ll still be delicious and get eaten plus you’ll learn a lot along the way!

IMG_2598For this batch, we made a classic “Everything Bagel” topping.  We love the garlic.  We love the onion.  Most people probably don’t love us quite so much when we’re breathing on them with our garlic-onion breath for the rest of the day, but so it goes. 

You’ll notice in the pictures that Cori looks pretty spiffy.  That’s because one of the wonderful things about making bagels is that you can make them the day before, put them in the fridge then just take them out in the morning to boil and bake.  Easy!   We love them hot out of the oven with butter or as an egg sandwich!

IMG_2617Let the kids into the kitchen when you start shaping these.  They’ll love it!!!  If you do some experimenting, let me know how they come out.  If you have any tips or tricks…..please post them here! I’d also love to hear about any of your first encounters with a bagel!  :)   Please feel free to share this post with someone who might like to start experimenting along with us!  Don’t forget to like Kneading Life on Facebook and join my contact list at the top of the page!

Enjoy your time around the bread bowl or come knead with me this Saturday at 9 am: Upcoming Classes.


*This bagel recipe is a modified version of “My Best Bagels” from Bread Alone.

My Best Bagels

1 1/4 cups non-chlorinated water

4 tsp yeast

1/2 cup whole wheat flour

1 T. fine sea salt

2 1/2- 3 cups all-purpose flour

1 egg white, lightly beaten


Combine the yeast and water in a large bowl.  Stir until yeast dissolves.  Add the whole wheat flour, salt, and enough white flour to make a thick mass that is difficult to stir.

IMG_2553Turn out onto a lightly floured surface and knead, adding more of the remaining flour until the dough is soft and smooth, approximately15 minutes.  I like to add enough flour to make it a dough that’s firm but pliable.

Let the dough rise, covered, until doubled in volume.

Divide the dough into 8 pieces.

IMG_2559Flatten slightly, pull the edges to the center, pinch ends, flip, and roll into a tight ball.  Allow to rise again for the gluten to rest and lend itself to easy shaping; 10 minutes.

IMG_2561Push your finger through the center of each ball and gently pull to widen the hole so that it takes on a bagel shape.

Cover with a damp towel or plastic wrap and place in a moderately warm draft free place (74-80 degrees) for 10 minutes.

*Note I wanted hot bagels in the morning so I started late in the day then at this point, I put mine on a cornmeal dusted cookie sheet, covered them in plastic wrap, and put them in the fridge to finish when I woke up!  You could continue right on to boiling if you’d rather.  Just make sure before you start boiling them that you test one to be sure it floats when you put it in so that you know they’re ready for this step!  If it doesn’t float pull it right out and wait a bit.

The bagels after rising in the fridge!

The bagels after rising in the fridge!

Preheat the oven to 425 degrees at least 30 minutes before baking with a baking stone centered in the oven.  If you don’t have a baking stone, make due with a parchment lined cookie sheet that has been dusted with cornmeal.

Combine 3 quarts water and 2 T. barley malt syrup (I didn’t).  I’ve also read that you can boil the bagels in a large pot with 1/4 cup honey.  This time, I opted for Peter Reinhardt’s method of adding a tablespoon of baking soda to a boiling pot of water.

Place bagels into the boiling water.  After 1 minute flip them over and boil for another minute.  Remove with a slotted spoon to a parchment-lined sheet pan that has been dusted with cornmeal.  You can do them a minute longer if you like your bagels chewy.

IMG_2579Brush with beaten egg white and topping if you want.  I like to use equal amounts of poppy seeds, sesame seeds, dried garlic, and dried onions with a bit of salt.

Place the bagels on the middle shelf of the oven and bake until lightly golden; approximately 15 – 20 minutes.

If you can stand waiting, cool them till they’re at least just warm.  Slather with butter or cream cheese and enjoy!


 Recipe index

Story index

Want to experiment with another fun bread?  Try Scavenger’s Bread and take a trip through your own kitchen cupboards!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>