No-good-reason-not-to-make-it English Muffin Bread

As luck would have it, after writing about a Coda with my Mom, I found myself on the road again on a whirlwind trip to Massachusetts where I would be, once again, in the kitchen with my good friend, Nancy.  It wasn’t a surprise when I asked if we could make her English Muffin Bread together.  She’d been thinking the same thing so we were on the same page…until we started looking over the recipe and pondering ingredients.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERABecause it was the first time I’d be making English Muffin Bread, I wanted to stay true to the recipe.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA“But I like to change it up a bit,” Nancy started to say, “maybe we’ll add some oats and….”

Feeling a little bit of angst rise up, I tried to explain that I wanted to see how the recipe came out as written before playing with the proportions and ingredients. I took a breath reminding myself that I had a lot of kitchen-history with Nancy.  We could make it work.

“Let’s just split the recipe in half and I’ll make the original and you can make yours with a little of this and that,” I proposed.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA In retrospect, I should’ve thought this through because Nancy and I sometimes find ourselves in all kinds of predicaments over what seem to be great ideas. 

Every Lucy needs and Ethel, right?

I donned my new apron (a souvenir from my pilgrimage to France!) and started to help get ingredients out.

The free-for-all started.  “We’re not competing,” Nancy chimed in as she scooped flour into her bowl.

I eyed the amount of flour in the jar.  “It was going to be close.”  She seemed to notice at the same time and offered to scoop some of her white flour out and add some wheat flour in.”  She was in motion before I had time to re-measure.


Dueling bowls…Let the games begin!

“Oh well,” I thought, “it’s just a little flour.”

After measuring out her yeast she stopped abruptly, “Oh, Mary,” she said looking at the nearly empty jar, “I hope there’s enough yeast or yours is going to stink.”

“Did she just say my bread might stink?” I laughed out loud.  So did she.

After that, I’m not sure what Nancy added into her bowl because I was too busy trying to keep track of what I was doing!  She’s a scavenger tinker-er (in many of the same ways I wrote about in the post about Darrell’s escapades!)  Her bread had some extra flour, some whole wheat flour, and some oats.  She substituted all water for milk.

None of it seemed to matter because by the time the frenzy was over, we both had batter to pour into our pans!

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAWhile I stayed true to the recipe, I have to admit that both loaves were exceptional!

Can you see the difference between the loaves?

Can you see the difference between the loaves?

I can’t imagine one good reason not to make this English Muffin Bread.  It’s easy, doesn’t require you to knead, requires just one rise in the pan, freezes well, and toasts up great!  Consider making it the night before and it’ll be ready to toast up fresh in the morning!

Get your apron, grab a kid to help you mix, and don’t ever look back!  You’ll love this!


5-6 cups flour

1/4 tsp baking soda


1/2 cup water

2 cups milk

1 Tbsp sugar

2 tsp salt

Combine 3 cups flour (measure by spooning lightly into a cup), yeast, sugar, salt, and baking soda.

Heat liquids till warm (120 – 130 degrees) Add the liquid to the dry ingredients and beat well.  *Note, I didn’t heat my liquids and the only difference we noted was that mine took much longer to rise.

Continue to add remaining flour until you have a stiff batter.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAGrease two 8 x 4 inch bread pans and sprinkle generously with cornmeal (just like and English muffin would have!)

Pour batter in and sprinkle generously with more cornmeal!

Let rise 45 minutes or until double in size.

Bake at 450 degrees for 25 minutes.

Remove from pan immediately after baking.

Makes 2 loaves


As always, I hope we find ourselves together in the future around the bread bowl or sitting at the table with a cup of coffee and a slice or two of toasted English Muffin Bread!  Enjoy!

If you enjoyed this post, think about adding your email address to my mailing list using the link at the top of the page so you’ll stay current with what’s happening with Kneading Life!  You might also consider sharing this post if you think others would like to try making English Muffin Bread! Thanks for reading and for your support!

While the bread is rising what else is there for Nancy to do but hoola hoop on the patio???  :)

While the bread was rising what else could Nancy to do but hula hoop on the patio???


Recipe index

Story Index

The Original Scavenger’s Bread

Mary’s bio

An Invitation






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>